"Monthly Giving Builder made the work feel possible again."
- Sydney Zetune, Executive Director, FEAST
Listen to The Podcast for Marketers Looking to Amplify Their Online Presence
I believe positive stories of change can transform our world to be a better place. That’s why I teach nonprofits how to use social media ads to attract potential supporters to their cause and create sustainable giving models by building monthly giving programs for everyone to become a philanthropist.
We made it. The final State of Recurring Giving of 2026 is in the books, and here is the headline: about half of nonprofits sign up zero new monthly donors. Zero.
Watch the replay, grab the takeaways, and how we can fix that stat before GivingTuesday on December 1 and into 2027!
These are not your average webinars. The chat was alive, the questions were great, and I picked up a few new ideas myself.
Here is who joined me on November 17, in partnership with GoFundMe Pro:
Jump to the part you need:
Short on time? Start here.
Because half of nonprofits are not asking.
Luca shared data from the Fundraising Effectiveness Project, which is a collaboration between GivingTuesday Data Commons and the AFP Foundation for Philanthropy. Over four years, the share of donors giving on a recurring schedule went from 6.6% to 7.9%. That is growth. It is also pretty modest.
Here is the part that stopped me. In 2021, 47% of organizations in the panel signed up zero new recurring donors. In 2025, it was 49%. Zero. Year after year.
I am not saying half of your new donors should go monthly. I am saying zero is a number we can beat.
The small lift we do see comes mostly from existing monthly donors who keep giving. Not from new ones joining.
Your move: Put a monthly option in front of every new donor. Every form. Every campaign. Every time.
Active monthly donors give one-time gifts on top of their monthly gift. Passive monthly donors set it and forget it. About 70% are passive and 30% are active.
This matters, because active donors are worth a lot more:
Someone in the chat asked a great question.
Does asking a passive donor for a one-time gift turn them into an active donor? Luca was honest. The data cannot prove that. The extra gift is more likely a sign of a deeper relationship that already exists.
I would also widen the word active. A monthly donor who volunteers, sits on your board, or opens every email is active too. Luca said GivingTuesday Data Commons hopes to track those non-money actions in the future.
Your move: Find out how many of your monthly donors are active and how many are passive. Some passive donors will stay passive, and that is fine. Segment them anyway, then invite them to give an extra gift on their own schedule, with their own message.
Yes. A donor who gives less is better than a donor who leaves.
When monthly donors change their plan, upgrades and downgrades are both rare. Most just cancel. For every downgrade, there are about 36 cancels. That is a shame, because look at what happens next. Luca followed donors who changed their plan in 2022 and checked on them in 2023:
| What the donor did in 2022 | Still giving in 2023 |
|---|---|
| Downgraded their monthly gift | 93% |
| Cancelled but kept giving
one-time gifts |
About 63% |
The 63% is good news. A donor who cancels and gives a one-time gift is still in your corner. Still, the monthly donor who gave a little less stays much closer.
This is not only a nonprofit thing. In the subscription world, Recurly’s State of Subscriptions research shows over 50% of people choose to pause or downgrade when they are given the chance. I talked about this at the Monthly Giving Summit in February.
Monthly donors also get safer over time. About 22% of second-year monthly donors stop giving the next year. For long-time monthly donors, it is 13%. The steepest drop happens around the first anniversary, so that first year is where your relationship work counts most.
Your move: Test your cancel flow today. Pretend you are a donor and click cancel. What pops up? Then add a lower-amount option and a pause option, and make one of them the first choice.
Q4 is one-time giving season. GivingTuesday is your chance to change the story.
Last year’s Q4 was strong. Dollars were up 10%, and more new donors gave their first gift than in any year since 2020. Still, monthly giving made up only 14% of Q4 dollars and 2% of Q4 donors. December one-time giving is more than double a normal month, and recurring barely moves.
Now the good news. On GivingTuesday, about 3.4 times as many people sign up for a monthly gift as on a normal day. And one-time donors you win on GivingTuesday turn into monthly donors later at the same rate as donors from the rest of the year. They are open to it. They just did not start there.
Here is how I think about it. We are creatures of habit, and we take the action we are invited to take. Invite people to monthly giving, and many will say yes. I would love to bring Luca back next Q4 so we can see what happened in 2026.
Your move: Ask new donors to start a monthly gift on GivingTuesday. Then test different ways to say it.
On purpose. One year at a time. Over 10 years, Second Harvest went from 200 monthly donors to more than 4,300, and their recurring revenue grew from 17% to 38% of total revenue. That is the number I want every one of us to chase.
The word I kept coming back to as I listened to Maria was intentional. Here is what that looks like:
Maria also shared something honest. Right now, they cancel donors who say they cannot keep giving. They do not offer a lower amount yet. After hearing Luca’s data, she plans to talk with her donor services person about trying a downgrade option.
I love that. We are all learning together.
GivingTuesday is December 1. Here is what I would do.
The chat came with great questions. Here are the ones I hear most.
Share a story of hope. Maria sends donor newsletters and impact stories by email and direct mail, and they often bring in gifts. Some perform better than a regular ask. Staying quiet is the real risk, because donors forget you. I always say, be top of mind. When someone hears “GivingTuesday,” which cause do they think of first?
Maria asks once. When a monthly donor gives on GivingTuesday, she takes them out of the mid-December campaign. She still sends a December 31 email when a big match is running, and she always thanks them for the gifts they already gave.
Start with donors who gave several times during the year, not just once. Segment them and test the group against your other audiences.
Look at your own donor file, and call monthly giving a “yes and.” Monthly donors also give one-time gifts in November and December. Michelle shared that GoFundMe Pro customers who run recurring programs see about 10 times the lifetime value over time. Show leadership revenue they can count on every year, not a fresh start every January.
There is no magic number. Look at your team’s capacity and your full plan. In my experience, most nonprofits under-email. People often need to see you 8 to 10 times before they act. Maria sends two emails a week starting in November, and many of those are stewardship and impact emails, not asks.
Use other channels. Call last year’s donors to thank them, then use email for the wider ask. You can also send texts, or upload a small list to Meta and retarget those donors with ads. Add an impact email next to your ask emails.
Be intentional with your copy. Describe monthly giving as joining a community, on the form and in your emails. A monthly-only landing page and form also helps donors make a clear choice.
In Maria’s experience, a two-times match made little difference compared with no match. Three-times and four-times matches did increase giving. Even without a match, people still gave. Do not discount the generosity that is already there.
Second Harvest has gathered birthdays in many ways over 10 years, including email sign-ups and purchased data. They send about 200 birthday cards to monthly donors each month, plus birthday emails.
Thank you to GoFundMe Pro for partnering with us on this series. Thank you to Luca, Michelle, and Maria for sharing so openly. And thank you to this community for bringing the energy every single time.
Have a fabulous GivingTuesday!!!
Dana
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
ABOUT
BOOK
mastermind
monthly Giving
speaking
media
contact
blog
copyright © positive equation 2022. All rights reserved
Enter your email below and I'll send you my 5-Step Framework Podcast Series with strategies you can implement RIGHT away to grow your monthly donors!
Sign up for text updates. By participating, you agree to the terms & privacy policy for automated messages from Positive Equation to the phone number you provide. No consent required to buy. Msg&data rates may apply.
Let's grow your monthly donors, together!
privacy policy

Comments